رد الشبهات عن رسول الله
The devil says Muhammad tried to kill himself

The libel:

Muhammad tried to commit suicide more than once, out of grief for the death of Waraka Ibn Nawfal. He was training him and translating The Old Testament and the Bible for him. After his death the visits of the revelation became rare. So, Muhammad tried to get rid of his life. The devil's worshippers wonder how Prophet Muhammad could think of such a horrible sin, trying to prove that lie with a hadith in Sahih Al-Bukhari.

 

Repelling off the Libel:

               We should first mention the books that tell that story:

 1) The trusted narrations):

               AlSayeda A'esha in (Sahih AlBukhary)

                AlSayeda A'esha in (AbdulRazzak book)

                AlSayeda A'esha in (Musnad Ahmad)

2) The weak narrations:

                 Ibn Abbas in (AlThurreyah AlTaherah)

                 It was narrated by Othman Ibn Ataa who was                               categorized by the Hadith specialists to be weak and                    telling made up ahadith. AlDarcotni said that he was                   trusted as a person, but he never met Ibn Abbas.

                 Moreover, AlBukhary categorized him among the                        weak narrators and Ibn AlMusayeb denied his                              narration.

3) That hadith includes a weak part which is the narrator's words:

                The Revelation's visits became rare and the Prophet PBUH was very sad…..etc. In that part he mentioned that the Prophet fell off the high mountains. This part was not narrated in the hadith in the following trusted hadith referrals:

Sahih AlBukhari       Sahih Muslim    Musnad Ahmad

 

That extra part is too weak to be trusted. For, the Prophet never said I tried to commit suicide. AlSayeda A'esha didn't say that either. So, if Urwa Ibn Masoud narrated the hadith after he learnt it from AlSayeda A'esha he wouldn't say (We were informed). All these clues deny the existence of that made up part in the hadith. It was not said by any of the Prophet's companions or followers. So, it is rootless and can't be said by the Prophet.

 

4) The clause (We were informed) was deliberately added to the hadith. But nobody knows who added it or why.

 

5) As to the credibility of that story and its origins, they are completely confused. The Prophet's personality was all the time well- known as stable and confident. How could such a balanced person try to kill him self? He was brave and accomplished. Even before the Islamic Message he was saved by Allah to be able to carry such a heavy burden. No bad deeds or pre-Islamic habits were proved to be done by him.

القرآن الكريم
القرآن الكريم مقروءا
ترتيلات القرآن الكريم
تسجيلات نادرة القرآن الكريم
نور النبي
رسول الله في أعين محبيه
رد الشبهات عن رسول الله
آل بيت رسول الله
صحابة رسول الله
أضف لمعلوماتك الإسلامية
المنتدى الإسلامي
البحث في الملفات
 
البحث في المقالات
 
السيرة النبوية
مقروءة
مسموعة
نور النبي
المكتبة الإسلامية
الكتب والبحوث
التسجيلات الصوتية
التسجيلات المرئية
نور النبي
المرأة والطفل
نصائح ذهبية
إيمانك يا مؤمنة
علمي طفلك الإيمان
نور النبي
Facebook
صفحة موقع نور النبي

صفحة فضيلة الشيخ
أبوهاشم الشريف
نور النبي
انت الزائر رقم 6386980
أخبار الموقع عن الموقع اتصل بنا رد الشبهات عن رسول الله آل بيت رسول الله الرئيسية
Powered By Ray-IT - All Rights Reserved 2006